Research Brief · August 2026
Who gets paid first? Start there.
A private investment can have a compelling asset, a credible sponsor, and a return target that looks attractive. The structure still determines who is rewarded, when they are paid, and what happens when the plan falls short.
By Andrew Davis Educational research 8 minute read
The finding that changes the order of diligence
A 2024 private-markets study estimated that 53% to 75% of intermediation costs were attributable to nonperformance fees.
The study covered private markets broadly, not only private real estate. Its implication is still useful: before debating the return target, identify the costs that accrue without a successful investor outcome and determine how they affect the sponsor's incentives.
A practical lens
Read the documents through the Three A's.
A Alignment
Who contributes cash, who gets paid first, which fees exist regardless of performance, and what the sponsor gives up if results fall short?
A Asymmetry
Is the claimed edge specific, testable, and supported by a relevant record, operating evidence, and a credible downside case?
A Accountability
What must be reported, how will actual results be compared with underwriting, and who owns the response when conditions change?
Document review
Five checks before the projected return gets a vote.
01
Build one complete compensation map
List every payment to the sponsor and its affiliates, including acquisition, asset management, construction management, financing, disposition, property management, guaranty, refinancing, and organizational fees. Mark when each fee is earned, who calculates it, and whether it is paid before investors receive capital or a preferred return.
Request: the operating agreement, private placement memorandum, subscription documents, and a single fee schedule tied back to page and section references.
02
Separate performance pay from activity pay
A promote can align incentives only if the hurdle, catch-up, waterfall, and calculation base are clear. Fees earned for buying, financing, managing, or selling an asset may be payable regardless of the investor outcome. Evaluate the full package, not one headline percentage.
Request: a worked waterfall for the base case, downside case, early sale, refinancing, and a result below the preferred return.
03
Verify the sponsor's capital at risk
Ask how much cash the sponsor and its decision-makers invest, when that cash is funded, whether it sits on substantially the same economic terms, and whether any of it is financed, reimbursed, or offset by fees. A stated commitment is not the same as funded capital.
Request: funded-capital evidence, the sponsor subscription, capital-account treatment, and written disclosure of any offsets or different rights.
04
Trace conflicts and related-party economics
Related parties may provide property management, construction, financing, brokerage, or other services. Identify who selects those firms, how pricing is tested, whether contracts can be terminated, and which party benefits when costs rise.
Request: the conflicts section, affiliate agreements, pricing policy, approval process, and any investor or advisory-committee rights.
05
Make accountability a written obligation
Reporting should show actual results against the original underwriting, explain material variances, identify debt and liquidity pressure, and state who owns the response. A polished update without variance analysis is communication, not accountability.
Request: the contractual reporting cadence, a representative report, valuation policy, debt summary, reserve policy, and material-change notification process.
The meeting checklist
Eight questions that make the structure visible.
01 Which payments are earned even if investors lose money?
02 Who receives cash before investors recover contributed capital?
03 What compensation is deferred, returned, or lost when results fall short?
04 How much sponsor cash is funded, and on what economic terms?
05 Can every affiliate payment and conflict be found in one schedule?
06 Does the downside case show debt pressure, new capital needs, and exit constraints?
07 Will reporting compare actual performance with the original underwriting?
08 Who is accountable when an assumption, budget, or timeline changes?
Method and sources
Start with primary documents. Keep the limits visible.
This field guide synthesizes independent academic research and investor education published by the SEC. It is a diligence framework, not a rating of a particular sponsor or offering. The SEC notes that private-placement documents typically are not reviewed by a regulator and may provide limited disclosure. Offering documents, audited financials, funded-capital evidence, and written sponsor responses remain the controlling evidence for a specific opportunity.
1
Accessing Private Markets: What Does It Cost? ↗
CFA Institute Research and Policy Center
Wayne Lim, Financial Analysts Journal, Volume 80, Issue 4, 2024.
2
Private Placements under Regulation D ↗
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Investor Bulletin, updated August 17, 2022. Covers disclosure, illiquidity, offering documents, Form D, and diligence questions.
3
How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio ↗
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Investor Bulletin, July 23, 2025. Explains how fees reduce the capital that remains invested and compounding.
Put it to work
Score the evidence you have. Turn every unclear answer into a document request.
The Equity Check Sponsor Alignment Scorecard applies these questions across Alignment, Asymmetry, and Accountability. It is educational and does not recommend or rate an investment.
The short version
Return targets describe a possibility. Payment priority describes the structure.
Map every sponsor and affiliate payment.
Verify funded sponsor capital and economic terms.
Model the waterfall below the preferred return.
Make reporting and variance explanations explicit.
About the author
Andrew Davis
Over the last 5 years, Andrew has built and led investor relations teams at two large private equity firms. Those teams raised over $500M and served nearly 2,000 investors.
Important: This material is for educational purposes only. Equity Check is not a registered broker-dealer, investment adviser, or financial planner with the SEC, FINRA, or any state regulatory authority. Equity Check does not provide investment advice, manage portfolios, or make recommendations. Private investments are illiquid and involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Review the governing offering documents and consult your own legal, tax, and financial professionals before making an investment decision.
